Churches in Shelter Island, NY

Find a church in Shelter Island, NY. We list 3 churches here, each with a transparent Guide Score and member reviews so you can compare worship style, teaching, and welcome before you visit.

Refine in search →

Manhanset ChapelShelter Island, NY

Unrated

Worship—

Worship: not rated

Preaching—

Preaching: not rated

Welcome—

Welcome: not rated

Shelter Island Presbyterian ChurchPresbyterian · Shelter Island, NY

Unrated

Worship—

Worship: not rated

Preaching—

Preaching: not rated

Welcome—

Welcome: not rated

Saint Marys Episcopal ChurchEpiscopal Church · Shelter Island, NY

Unrated

Worship—

Worship: not rated

Preaching—

Preaching: not rated

Welcome—

Welcome: not rated